How to Think About Mutual Fund Performance — Like a Real Investor

🧠 How to Think About Mutual Fund Performance (Without Losing Sleep)

Feeling uneasy because some of your mutual funds aren’t performing well? Don’t worry—it's actually a sign that your portfolio is working. A mix of both performing and underperforming funds is essential for long-term growth. Here's why...


🤔 Seen Some Funds Underperforming? Don’t Panic Just Yet

Q: Is it okay to have a mix of performing and underperforming funds?
A: Absolutely. That’s how diversification works—everything shouldn’t move in the same direction all the time.

Let’s break that down, especially for those who check fund returns a bit too often (you’re not alone).


🍛 Your Portfolio Is Like a Thali

Imagine a well-served Indian thali—sweet, salty, tangy, filling, and a little bitter too.

Not every item is your favorite. But together? It balances out beautifully.

Mutual fund portfolios work the same way.

  • Some funds are there for growth (they're spicy 🔥).
  • Some provide stability (comfort food, really).
  • Others sit quietly, waiting for their chance to shine (you’ll be glad they’re there when markets turn).

If every fund is doing great at once? That’s either luck… or a risk waiting to explode.


🧩 Different Funds, Different Jobs

One common mistake I’ve seen among new investors is judging every fund by the same yardstick: "Is it beating the market?"

But that’s like comparing a bowler to a batsman. They're not meant to do the same job.

Here’s what I mean:

  • A large-cap fund adds long-term consistency.
  • A mid-cap or small-cap fund brings in punchy growth—but with higher swings.
  • A debt fund may seem “boring,” but it’s your safety net.
  • A hybrid or balanced fund does a little bit of everything—it’s your all-rounder.

So yes, some funds will underperform when their part of the market is out of favor. But that’s not a design flaw. It’s how portfolios are meant to work.


📉 Underperformance Isn't Always a Bad Sign

Let’s say you have a mid-cap fund that’s been sluggish for a year.

You start thinking—“Should I switch to that trending large-cap fund?”

Hold on.

That mid-cap fund might just be in a temporary lull. Market leadership rotates all the time. What’s lagging today may lead tomorrow.

I’ve seen this cycle play out so many times in offline conversations.
People switch out of underperforming funds—only to watch them rally after they exit.


🛠️ What You Should Be Watching

If a fund is underperforming, here’s how to evaluate it:

  • How long has it underperformed?
    A few months = normal. 3+ years = worth reviewing.
  • Is it underperforming its category and benchmark?
    If others in the same category are doing better, dig deeper.
  • Has the fund changed strategy or fund manager?
    Sometimes, internal shifts affect performance—and that matters.

🧠 The Real Point of Diversification

Diversification doesn’t mean “everything will go up together.”

It means “something will hold when others fall.”

  • When equity falls, debt cushions you.
  • When mid-caps fall, large-caps may stay flat.
  • When the market panics, your hybrid fund might just buy the dip for you.

A mix of winners and laggards is actually a sign that your money isn’t overexposed to one trend or theme.

📝 Quote to Remember:
“A good portfolio is like a cricket team. Not everyone hits sixes—but every player matters.”


🙋‍♀️ Reader FAQ

Q1: Do I need to remove underperforming funds immediately?
Not necessarily. Check if they’re just out of favor or fundamentally broken. Patience often pays.

Q2: How often should I review fund performance?
Every 6 to 12 months is fine. Don’t check daily—it only adds stress.

Q3: What if I can’t tell which funds are working for me?
That’s okay. Many people feel this way. Consider a professional review—offline, of course.


👣 Final Thought

If you're staring at your portfolio and wondering why some parts feel sluggish, that might actually be a good thing. It means you’re not betting your entire future on just one outcome.

And if you’re still unsure whether your mix of funds is balanced for your life goals—well, that’s where personal, offline conversations matter more than online returns.

Your financial life deserves a strategy—not just star ratings.

Comments

About the Author

Anindya Ray is an AMFI-registered Mutual Fund Distributor and an IRDAI-licensed Insurance Agent. With hands-on experience in helping people make informed financial decisions and spreading personal finance awareness, he is deeply committed to guiding Indian families through their financial journey with clarity, confidence, and purpose.

Driven by the belief that financial literacy is the foundation of financial freedom, Anindya works at the grassroots level to simplify complex topics like investing, insurance, and money habits for everyday individuals across all walks of life.

The SIP Sage is his personal initiative—a non-commercial financial awareness blog—dedicated to breaking down money matters into easy, relatable insights for the Indian middle class.

Note: No online services or products are offered or solicited through this platform. For offline, personalized financial guidance, Anindya may be contacted directly via WhatsApp or email.